Baked Oysters

Baked oysters are an easy way to serve shellfish to anyone who is not sure about eating them raw. Each oyster is topped with a paste of butter, garlic, parsley, Parmesan and breadcrumbs, then baked for 10 minutes at 200°C until the crumb is golden and the butter is bubbling. Six oysters each makes a generous starter for two, and the only tricky part is opening the shells.

Jump to recipe
Baked oysters with a golden garlic butter and breadcrumb topping on a tray
Total
30 min
Prep
20 min
Cook
10 min
Serves
2
Per serving
340kcal

Keeping baked oysters juicy

The aim is a hot, plump oyster under a crisp, savoury topping, and the key is not to overcook it. At 200°C the oysters need only 10 minutes, long enough to cook them through and brown the crumb, but not so long that they shrink. Leave the oyster liquid in the shell when you open it, because it keeps the oyster moist and helps carry the flavour of the garlic butter.

Buying them well matters just as much. Native British oysters are in season from September to April, while Pacific (rock) oysters are available all year round and are the usual choice for baking. Buy them from a fishmonger or a good fish counter, on the day you want to cook them. They must be alive: the shells should be tightly closed and feel heavy for their size. Keep them in the fridge, covered with a damp cloth, until you are ready to start.

Opening oysters takes a little practice, and the knife can slip. Use a proper oyster knife, a folded tea towel to protect your hand, and a firm work surface. If you would rather not, ask the fishmonger to open them for you.

Baked oysters, step by step

Tap a time to start a timer.

  1. Heat the oven and clean the oysters Heat the oven to 200°C (180°C fan), gas 6. Scrub the shells under cold running water. Throw away any oysters with broken shells, or any that are open and do not close when tapped.
  2. Open the oysters Fold the tea towel over your hand and hold an oyster flat side up, with the hinge facing you. Push the tip of the oyster knife into the hinge and twist to pop it open. Slide the blade along the top shell to cut the muscle and lift the lid off. Loosen the oyster from the bottom shell, keeping the liquid in the shell, and check for bits of broken shell.
  3. Make the topping In a small bowl, mix the butter, garlic, parsley, breadcrumbs, Parmesan and pepper into a thick paste.
  4. Set up the tray Scrunch the foil into small rings and set them on a baking tray. Nestle each oyster in its bottom shell on a ring so that it sits level and the juices do not spill.
  5. Top and bake Spoon about 1 teaspoon of the topping over each oyster and press it down lightly. Bake for , until the crumb is golden, the butter is bubbling and the oysters are plump and steaming hot.
  6. Serve Carefully lift the hot shells onto plates with tongs and serve straight away with the lemon wedges.

What to serve with baked oysters

Serve them as a starter, with lemon wedges, brown bread and butter and a glass of dry white wine or sparkling wine. Scattered chopped chives or a few drops of hot sauce add a bit of heat. If you prefer a crisp, battered version, deep-fried oysters are another good way to cook them. For a larger shellfish starter, try garlic-marinated langoustines.

Swaps and ideas

Replace the parsley with chives or tarragon, or add the zest of half a lemon to the topping. A teaspoon of Pernod, in the style of oysters Rockefeller, goes well with the garlic butter. For a lighter topping, use only the breadcrumbs, a little oil and the lemon zest.

Common problems and fixes for Baked Oysters

The oysters are small and rubbery.
They have baked for too long. Ten minutes at 200°C is enough, so take them out as soon as the crumb is golden and the edges of each oyster have curled.
The topping is soggy instead of crisp.
The paste was too buttery or the oysters were too wet. Spoon on only a teaspoon of paste per oyster, use dry breadcrumbs, and if the crumb is pale at the end, put the tray under a hot grill for 1–2 minutes.
The shells tip over and the butter spills.
The shells are curved, so they need support. Sit each one in a ring of scrunched foil, as in the fourth step, and make sure the tray is level.

Frequently asked questions about Baked Oysters

How can you tell when baked oysters are cooked?

The topping is golden and bubbling, the edges of the oyster have curled, and the oyster is plump and steaming hot. This usually takes 10 minutes at 200°C.

Can you prepare baked oysters ahead of time?

Yes, but only for a short time. Open and top the oysters up to 2 hours ahead, keep them covered on a tray in the fridge and bake them just before serving.

Can I ask the fishmonger to open the oysters?

Yes, and it saves effort. Ask them to keep the oyster and its liquid in the bottom shell, then cook them the same day.

What can I use instead of Parmesan?

Mature Cheddar or Gruyère both work, in the same quantity. Parmesan is made with animal rennet, so choose a vegetarian hard cheese if you need one.

How did you like the recipe?

4.8 / 5 · 7 ratings