Potato Pie

Potato pie is a double-crust pie of thinly sliced potatoes, soft fried onions and sharp Cheddar, bound with a little cream. Par-boiling the slices before they go into the pastry means they cook through in the time the crust needs to turn golden. It makes a filling meat-free supper for six, hot with greens or cold the next day.

Jump to recipe
Potato pie with a golden shortcrust lid, cut to show layers of potato, onion and Cheddar
Total
1 h 30 min
Prep
25 min
Cook
55 min
Serves
6
Per serving
700kcal

Common mistakes with potato pie

The potatoes and the base need attention. Thick slices stay hard in the middle, so slice them to an even 3mm. Wet potatoes make the base soggy, so drain and steam-dry them well. Keep the shortcrust cold while you work, and do not stretch it when lining the dish, or it will shrink back in the oven.

A pie like this is quite rich, so season with care. The Cheddar and the pastry are both salty, so use only the amount of salt in the recipe.

Potato pie method

Tap a time to start a timer.

  1. Heat the oven Heat the oven to 200°C (180°C fan), gas 6 and put a baking tray on the middle shelf to heat up. The hot tray helps the base of the pie to cook crisp.
  2. Par-boil the potatoes Slice the potatoes about 3mm thick. Boil them in well-salted water for , until just tender but not breaking up. Drain in a colander and leave to steam dry while you cook the onions.
  3. Cook the onions Melt the butter in a frying pan over a medium heat and cook the onions for , stirring, until soft and golden. Tip them into a large bowl with the potatoes, Cheddar, cream, salt and pepper and mix gently.
  4. Line the dish Roll out 300g of the pastry on a floured surface to about 3mm thick. Line the pie dish, letting the pastry hang over the edge. Prick the base with a fork.
  5. Fill and cover Pile in the filling and press it down lightly. Roll out the remaining pastry for the lid. Brush the rim of the base with beaten egg, lay on the lid and press the edges together to seal. Trim, crimp with a fork, cut a steam hole and brush all over with beaten egg.
  6. Bake Put the pie on the hot tray and bake for , until deep golden. If the top browns too quickly after , cover loosely with foil. Leave the pie to stand for before cutting.

Serving the pie

Serve hot with peas, buttered cabbage or a sharp green salad, and a spoonful of chutney or pickle. It is good cold too, which makes it a useful picnic or lunchbox option; a bowl of potato salad with vinaigrette would suit that. For a light starter on a cold evening, serve a small bowl of spinach soup first.

Common problems and fixes for Potato Pie

The base of the pie is soggy.
The filling was too wet or the base was not hot enough. Drain the potatoes well and let them steam dry, and always bake the pie on a preheated tray.
The potato is still hard in the middle.
The slices were too thick. Slice evenly at 3mm, which a mandoline makes easy, and make sure the potatoes are tender at the edges after boiling.
The filling is bland.
Use mature Cheddar and season the potato water well. A teaspoon of English mustard stirred into the filling gives it a kick without changing the character of the pie.

Frequently asked questions about Potato Pie

Can you make the pie ahead?

Yes. Assemble it up to 8 hours in advance, cover and keep it in the fridge, then glaze it just before baking. Add 5 minutes to the baking time when it goes in cold.

How do you store and reheat leftovers?

Keep it in the fridge for up to 3 days. Reheat slices at 180°C (160°C fan), gas 4, for 15 minutes until steaming hot all the way through, to keep the pastry crisp. It also tastes good cold.

What can you add to the filling?

Sliced leeks, crisp bacon or a few chopped herbs are all good. Soften the leeks with the onions first, and cook bacon until crisp before mixing it in.

Can you use ready-rolled pastry?

Yes. You need about 500g in total, which is usually two sheets. Use one for the base and one for the lid.

How did you like the recipe?

4.9 / 5 · 38 ratings