Oysters with Shallots
Oysters with shallots is the classic way to serve them raw: freshly opened, on a bed of ice, with a spoonful of finely diced shallot in red wine vinegar. The dressing is sharp enough to cut through the richness of the oyster without hiding its taste of the sea. Nothing is cooked, so the only skill is opening the shells, and the dressing can be made while you do it.

- Total
- 25 min
- Prep
- 15 min
- Serves
- 2
- Per serving
- 65kcal
Buying and preparing oysters with shallots
Buy live oysters from a fishmonger or a good supermarket fish counter, and ask when they came in. Native oysters are in season from September to April, and Pacific oysters are available all year. Pacific oysters are larger and milder, and are the better choice for a first go at opening them.
Keep them in the fridge until you are ready to open them. Once opened, they should be served within a few minutes, as they dry out and lose the liquid that gives them their flavour.
Preparing oysters with shallots
Tap a time to start a timer.
- Make the dressing Stir the diced shallot, red wine vinegar and pepper together in a small bowl. Leave it for while you open the oysters, so the shallot softens slightly.
- Scrub the oysters Scrub the shells under cold running water with a brush to remove grit and mud. Tap any that are open. If they do not close within a few seconds, throw them away, along with any that are cracked or feel light.
- Open them Fold a tea towel over your hand and hold an oyster with the flat shell on top and the hinge towards you. Push the tip of the knife into the hinge and twist until it pops. Slide the blade along the inside of the top shell to cut the muscle, then lift the shell off.
- Free the oyster Run the knife under the oyster to cut it loose, keeping the shell level so none of the liquid spills. Check for fragments of shell.
- Serve Pile crushed ice on a platter and nestle the oysters into it so they stay level. Spoon a little dressing over each one and serve straight away with lemon wedges and brown bread and butter.
Serving and variations
Brown bread and butter is the classic accompaniment. A splash of Tabasco is popular too, and a glass of Champagne or dry white wine is traditional. If you would rather cook them, try baked oysters or deep-fried oysters. Sherry vinegar is a good swap for red wine vinegar.
Common problems and fixes for oysters with Shallots
- The knife keeps slipping.
- The oyster is not held firmly. Wrap it in a folded tea towel on a worktop, keep the knife tip in the hinge and twist the blade rather than pushing harder.
- Bits of shell are floating in the oyster.
- The shell chipped as you opened it. Lift out the fragments with the tip of the knife and, if there is a lot, wipe the tip of the blade between oysters.
- The dressing is too harsh.
- The vinegar is overpowering the oyster. Use a little less vinegar, or add a pinch of caster sugar, and spoon on about half a teaspoon per oyster.
Frequently asked questions about oysters with Shallots
How many oysters per person?
Allow 6 per person as a starter and up to 12 as a main course.
How do you know if an oyster is fresh?
The shell should be tightly closed, or close when you tap it. It should feel heavy for its size and smell of the sea. Throw away any that stay open, have a broken shell or smell off.
How long do oysters keep in the fridge?
Eat them within 1–2 days of buying. Keep them cupped side down under a damp cloth, not in water or a sealed bag.
Is it safe to eat raw oysters?
Raw shellfish carry a higher risk of food poisoning than cooked, so buy from a reputable fishmonger. They are best avoided by pregnant women, young children, older people and anyone with a weakened immune system. Cooked oysters are a safer alternative.
How did you like the recipe?
4.7 / 5 · 4 ratings



